The Educational Policies for Confronting the Private Tutoring Phenomenon at the Pre-University Education in Egypt "An Analytical Study and Future Vision"

Abbas, Y. and Samhan, M. (2021). Elements of educational research in light of the requirements of the knowledge economy from the education professors' perspective at some Egyptian universities. Journal of the Faculty of Education, Ismailia, Faculty of Education, Ismailia, Suez Canal University, May, 50, 319-380.
Abdel-Ghani, N. and Ibrahim, R. (2023). Shadow education in secondary school in Egypt to achieve the principle of equity: Private centres and educational platforms as a model. Journal of the Faculty of Education, Beni Suef University, 20 (117).
Abdel-Qader, A. (2010). The role of educational research institutions in shaping educational policy in Egypt: A future study. World of Education, Arab Foundation for Scientific Consultations and Human Resources Development, 12(33), 341-354.
Abdel-Zaher, A. (2020). An analytical study of educational policy for developing the basic education stage in Egypt since 1980. Journal of Research in Education and Psychology, Faculty of Education, Minya University, 35(2), 21-40.
Abdullah, S. (2016). Private tutoring and their relationship to the regulatory regulations. The Second Scientific Conference of the Arab Society for Measurement and Evaluation entitled: Developing Pre-University Education - Future Visions, Arab Society for Measurement and Evaluation.
Abu Al-Makarem, J. (2009). Private Tutoring: A Systemic Issue and Societal Perspectives. (Alexandria: Dar Al-Jamia Al-Jadida).
Al-Adl, A. (2023). The social dimensions of student reluctance to attend secondary education: A field study on a sample of students and officials in Mansoura City. Annals of Arts, Ain Shams University, 51, 222-269.
Al-Adly, R. (2016). Eliminating private tutoring in pre-university education as an approach to education quality (Proposed Project). Scientific Journal of the Faculty of Specific Education, Menoufia University, 3.
Al-Adly, R. (2016). Eliminating private tutoring in pre-university education as an approach to education quality (Proposed Project). Scientific Journal of the Faculty of Specific Education, Menoufia University, 6(1), 507-538.
Al-Almai, A. (2008). Activating education policy in the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia for keeping up with educational trends: An analytical study. Journal of Educational Sciences, 15(4), 06-64.
Al-Azmi, et al. (2021). The phenomenon of private tutoring: A comparative study of Kuwait and Qatar universities. Educational Journal, Kuwait University, Scientific Publication Council, 35(139).
Al-Barbari, M. (2016). Developing higher education policies in Egypt to keep abreast of the knowledge economy by drawing on the experiences of Singapore and Malaysia. Journal of the Faculty of Education, Benha University, 106 (3), 117-244.
Al-Dahshan, G. (2015). Towards a critical perspective on Arab educational research. Journal of Criticism and Enlightenment Studies, 1, 15-31.
Al-Dami, S. (2017). The phenomenon of private tutoring: Causes and consequences: A field study in the city of Diwaniyah. Journal of Psychological, Educational, and Social Sciences Research, Lark Foundation for Philosophy, Linguistics, and Social Sciences, 25, 139-156.
Al-Hajri, R.; Al-Saqri, M.; Al-Tubi, A. and Hadrami, A. (2024). The educational effects of private tutoring on school education in the Sultanate of Oman from parents' perspective. Journal of Arab Research in the Fields of Specific Education, Arab Educators Association, 34, 29-51.
Al-Hajri, R.; Al-Farsi, A. and Al-Saqri, B. (2024). The social effects of private tutoring in the Sultanate of Oman. Arab Journal of Educational and Psychological Sciences, Arab League Educational, Cultural, and Scientific Organization, 36, 207-248.
Al-Harbi, S. (2007). Educational Policy: Concepts and Experiences. Riyadh, Al-Obeikan Library.
Al-Harbi, S. (2019). Educational Policy and its Role in Achieving the Fourth Goal of the Sustainable Development Goals: Education 2030: An Analytical Perspective. The Arab League Educational, Cultural and Scientific Organization (ALECSO), in cooperation with the Ministry of Education in the Kingdom of Bahrain, Tunis, 1-74.
Al-Hilaly, Al-Sh. (2021). The future of educational policy in Egypt after the COVID-19 pandemic. Journal of Qualitative Education Research, Mansoura University, 62, 2-26.
Al-Husseini, F. (2019). A future vision for educational development in Egypt. International Journal of Research in Educational Sciences, 2.
Al-Imam, S. (2016). Educational policy and the relationship between the Algerian University and the government: A systems analysis approach. Journal of Humanities and Social Sciences, University of Kasdi Merbah, Ouargla, Algeria, (27), 529-541.
Ali, A. (2015). Educational policy in pre-university education in light of the educational tree approach to confront the challenges of the info-media revolution. Journal of the Faculty of Education, Al-Azhar University, 166 (2), 90-237.
Ali, S. (1991). Ten pillars of education policy. Journal of Educational Studies, 6 (33), 13-19.
Ali, S. (1996). Education Policy in Egypt. Alam Al-Kutub, Cairo.
Ali, S. (1998). Education on the Threshold of the Twenty-First Century. Cairo, Modern World of Books.
Ali, S. (2017). Misguidance and Slander in the Education of the Poor. Alam Al-Kutub, Cairo.
Al-Khayat, L. (2021). Reasons for relying on private tutoring for primary school children and proposed solutions from the parents' perspective. Journal of Gulf and Arabian Peninsula Studies, Kuwait University, Academic Publication Council, 47(183), 217-260.
Al-Maliki, H. and Bashqa, S. (2019). Challenges facing the family in light of digital education and the problem of private tutoring. Arab Journal of Media and Child Culture, (6), 169-188.
Al-Mahdi, M. (2000). Public opinion trends towards school reinforcement groups as an alternative to private tutoring in public education in Egypt. Journal of Education, Al-Azhar University, Faculty of Education, 92.
Al-Mu'jam Al-Wasit. (1985). Chapter SAS, 480.
Al-Rashidi, A. (2014). Contemporary School Problems: Issues and Solutions. Egypt, Academic Library.
Al-Saab, R. (2011). Educational requirements for addressing private tutoring in public schools in Damietta Governorate. Reading and Knowledge Magazine, Egyptian Reading and Knowledge Association, 111, 45-68.
Al-Saab, R.  (2012). Private Tutoring in Public Education and their Relationship to Socio-Economic Factors in Damietta Governorate: A Field Study. Master's Thesis, Faculty of Education, Mansoura University.
Al-Sourti, Y. (2009). Authoritarianism in Arab Education. Alam Al-Ma'rifa Magazine, Kuwait, National Council for Culture, Arts, and Letters.
Al-Taher, R. and Qutit, A. (2018). A Proposed map for educational policy research in light of the sustainable development strategy of Egypt's vision 2030. Journal of Educational Sciences, Helwan University, 1(3), 32-108.
Al-Tamimi, E. (2014). The causes of the phenomenon of private tutoring and their educational effects on secondary school students in Zarqa Governorate. Journal of Educational Sciences, 41(2).
Al-Yafei, Sh. (2015). Community participation in educational policy-making in light of governance principles. World of Education Journal, Arab Foundation for Consulting and Human Resources Development, 16 (51), 1-30.
Al-Yafei, Sh. (2015). Educational policy-making: Concept and mechanisms. World of Education Journal, Arab Foundation for Consulting and Human Resources Development, 16 (50), 1-27.
Al-Zayoudi, M. (2016). Private tutoring among Saudi families and their attitudes towards it in light of some demographic variables. The Arabian Gulf Message, Arab Bureau of Education for the Gulf States, 37(141).
Ammar, H. (1996). The Bleeding of Private Tutoring: Studies in Education and Culture. Cairo, Arab House of Books Library.
Ammar, H. (1999). Towards Criminalizing Education Trafficking. Al-Ahram Newspaper, 2nd ed Year, 123, 979 (4), February 16, 1999.
Ammar, H.  and Ahmed, S. (2012). The Faithful Guide to the Education of Girls and Boys in the 21st Century. Egyptian Lebanese House, Cairo.
Awda, S. (2013). Issues in the World of Childhood. Amman, Jordan, Amwaj Printing, Publishing, and Distribution House.
Ayasra, M. (2011). Education Policies: Arab and Foreign Models. Amman, Wael Publishing House.
Bahi, O. (1999). The private tutoring phenomenon from the parents and school principals' perspective and its effect on the educational role of the school. An analytical field study. Journal of Education, Faculty of Education, Al-Azhar University, 82.
Bakr, A. (2006). Comparative Education and Educational Policies. Al-Salam Press, Kafr El-Sheikh.
Ben Ismail, F. (2019). Private tutoring: An educational reading of causes and effects. Scientific Horizons Journal, University of Kasdi Merbah, Algeria, 11(2), 374-398.
Ben Kheira, I. (2021). Private tutoring and their effect on the social relations of the educational group. A field study at a high school in the city of Djelfa. Journal of Education, Institute of Sciences and Technologies of Physical and Sports Activities, Ziane Achour University, Djelfa, 8(2), 192-213.
Bouanaqa, A. and Qarqazi, W. (2019). Private tutoring and their effect on the stability of the educational process. Journal of the Social Researcher, Abdelhamid Mehri University, 13, 157-168.
Boutiba, F. (2017). How much do Algerian families spend on private tutoring? Journal of Knowledge Groups, Ali Kafi University Center, Tindouf, 4.
Bissar, F. (2017). From the Reality of Educational Problems. Cairo, Modern Library for Publishing and Distribution.
Bray, M. (2022). Shadow Education in Africa: Supplementary Private Tutoring and its Policy Implications. United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization (UNESCO).
Cabinet. (2010). Parents' Opinion Survey on the Problem of Private Tutoring: A Comparative Report, Information and Decision Support Centre. Cairo.
Cabinet, Prime Ministerial Decision, No. (428) of (2013). Issuing the Executive Regulations for Chapter Seven of the Education Law promulgated by Law No. 139 of 1981, added by Law No. 155 of 2007 and amended by Law No. 93 of 2012.
Cabinet, Information and Decision Support Center. (2024). National Database for Studies, Bibliography on the Informal Economy and Summary of Study Recommendations, a monthly bulletin issued by the Information and Decision Support Centre of the Egyptian Cabinet, Issue 218, August, 1-36.
Central Agency for Public Mobilization and Statistics (2020). Key Indicators of Income, Prospects, and Consumption Research. October 2019 - March 2020, Cairo.
Diab, I. (2018). Developing educational policy for the twenty-first century teacher in Egypt in light of global best practices. Journal of Educational Administration, Egyptian Society for Comparative Education and Educational Administration, 5 (17), 341-417.
Dawidar, H. (2018). The Phenomenon of High School Students' Attendance at Private Tutoring Centres in Egypt: A Field Study. Master's Thesis, Faculty of Graduate Studies for Education, Cairo University.
Dawidar, H. (2022). Private tutoring: Causes, effects, and confrontation means. Educational Sciences, Cairo University, Faculty of Graduate Studies for Education, 30 (4).
Decision of the Minister of Education, No. (179) of 2015. Egyptian Gazette, No. 137, dated June 15, 2015, regarding the school discipline regulations specifying the rights and duties of students, the responsibilities of parents, and the powers of school staff, as well as the rights, responsibilities, and duties of teachers and school administration.
Eid, F. (2023). Shadow education policies in pre-university education in Egypt and South Korea: A comparative study. Journal of Comparative and International Education, Egyptian Society for Comparative Education and Educational Administration, 9(208), 11-55.
Eileen, M.; Jawhar, Y. and Makhlouf, S. (2019). Employing educational research results in educational policy-making in Egypt: A proposed conceptualization. Fayoum University Journal for Educational and Psychological Sciences, 13(4).
Fahmy, M. (1992). Reflections on education policy in Egypt. Journal of Educational Studies, Modern Education Association, 8(47), 10-28.
Farshan, L. & et al. (2004). Private  Tutoring: The Prevalence and Description of the Phenomenon. Algeria, Notebooks of the National Institute for Educational Research.
Fathi, E. (2022). A proposed model for enhancing strategic educational decision-making in Egypt in light of the regulatory framework for strategic governance of education. Journal of the Faculty of Education, Ain Shams University, 46 (3).
Fouad, Z. and Badran, S. (1989). Educational policies in Egypt in the 1980s. Contemporary Education Journal, Modern Education Association, 7(13), 211-250.
Gabr, Al-Mamoun A. (2015). The informal economy in Egypt: The model of private tutoring between legalization and cancellation. Scientific Journal of the Faculties of Commerce Sector, Al-Azhar University, 13, 506-615.
Ghanayem, M.  (2005). Educational research in the service of Arab society. A paper presented at the faculty scientific conference (7th Conference) entitled "The Role of Faculties of Education in Educational Reform," held at the Faculty of Education, Mansoura University, in collaboration with the Centre for Cognitive Studies, Cairo, November 12-13.
Ghanayem, M.  (2014). Educational Scientific Production in the Arab Environment: Reality and Hope. The 8th Arab Scientific Conference (5th International Conference on Educational Scientific Production in the Arab Environment: Value and Effect, April 26-27, 2014), 101-142. Sohag, Faculty of Education, Sohag University.
Ghanayem, M. (2018). Educational Policy, Class and Citizenship. The 12th Arab scientific conference, the 9th international conference on education, civil society and the culture of citizenship. Culture for Development Association, Sohag, 1, 519-546.
Ghanem, T.; Hassan, B. and Zamrud, A. (2021). Reasons for secondary school students' tendency to private tutoring from their parents' perspective: A field study in the city of Lattakia. Tishreen University Journal of Scientific Studies and Humanities, 43(5), 253-274.
Ghoneim, A. (2021). Rebuilding the value system in the new republic. Democracy Magazine, Al-Ahram Foundation, 21(83).
Ghoneim, A. (2022). Community participation in basic education in Egypt: Reality and hope. An analytical study. Journal of the Faculty of Education, Benha, 132(1), 3-28.
Ghoneim, S. (2015). Educational Policy in Egypt: Features and Challenges. The international conference of the national centre for educational research and development. "Education Policies in the Arab World: Challenges and Future Directions," in cooperation with the Arab Foundation for Scientific Consultations and Resource Development, June 13-14, 3-46.
Gouda, A. (2019). The economic effects of private tutoring in Egypt. Contemporary Egypt Journal, Egyptian Society for Political Economy, Statistics, and Legislation, 110(535), 425-468.
Hassan, H. (2007). Education and Contemporary Societal Issues in (Education and Society, Child Labor, Private Tutoring, Educational Bullying, and Extremism). Alexandria, Dar Al-Jamia Al-Jadida.
Hassanin, A. (2012). Educational policies and mechanisms for their development in Egypt. Journal of Scientific Research in Education, Faculty of Girls for Arts, Sciences, and Education, Ain Shams University, 13, 1437, (3), 1437-1469.
Hassanin, M. (2019). Proposed procedures for developing the selection process of educational policymakers in Egypt. Journal of Educational Administration, Egyptian Society for Comparative Education and Educational Administration, 6, (22), 359-449.
Hajji, A. (1987). Educational policy in Egypt and its implementation programs. Research papers from the conference towards a civilized educational project for Egypt. Modern Education Association, 4, 1317-1393.
Hijazi, M. (2019). Political dimensions and their implications for educational policy-making in Egypt: An analytical study. Faculty of Education Journal, Tanta University, 75(3), 627-645.
Ibrahim, M. (1970). Private Tutoring and Study Groups: Their Prevalence, Reasons, and Cost. Cairo, Dar El-Nasr Printing House.
Ibrahim, M. (2003). Public opinion trends towards private tutoring as reflected by Al-Ahram newspaper. Arab Foundation for Scientific Consultations and Human Resources Development, 4(11).
Ibrahim, M. (2014). Innovations in Pre-University Education: Thorny Challenges and Limited Progress. Cairo, Alam Al-Kutub.
Ibrahim, S.; Mahmoud, Y. and Ahmed, A. (2020). Some aspects of weak educational justice in modern and contemporary Egyptian education. Fayoum University Journal of Educational and Psychological Sciences, Faculty of Education, 14(12), 133-150.
Jad Al-Karim, A. and Al-Geyar, S. (2012). Educational policy and its mechanisms in Egypt. Journal of Scientific Research in Education, Ain Shams University, Faculty of Girls for Arts, Sciences and Education, 13 (3).
Kafoud, M. and et al. (2019). The phenomenon of private tutoring: Diagnosis and treatment. Journal of Education, (48).
Kamel, et al. (2017). Requirements for activating e-learning in public secondary education for addressing the problem of private tutoring in Port Said Governorate. Journal of the Faculty of Education, Port Said University, Faculty of Education, (22).
Karbash, Z. and Omair, S. (2024). Reasons for the spread of private tutoring: The perspective of 3rd year secondary school students: A field study on a sample of secondary schools in Skikda Province. Journal of Humanities and Social Sciences, Abdelhamid Mehri University, 10(1), 86-98.
Khawaldeh, A. and Hayasat S. (2017). Using scientific research results in decision-making among academic leaders in Jordanian universities. Journal of the Faculty of Education, Alexandria University, 27(1), 191-228.
Kidar, H. (2014). Private Tutoring and its Role in Declining Teacher Credibility: A Field Study in Some Secondary Schools in Algiers. Master's Thesis.
Lahbib, B. (2021). The effect of private tutoring on academic achievement: A field study on middle school students. Journal of Generation of Humanities and Social Sciences, Generation Centre for Scientific Research, (5).
Mahmoud, A. (2019). Educational research in Egypt in human development and community service: The crisis of reality and hopeful change. Research in Specific Education, (35), Faculty of Specific Education, Cairo University. 
Mahmoud N. (1999). A study of some dimensions of the private tutoring phenomenon in primary and preparatory education. Journal of the Faculty of Education, Aswan University - Faculty of Education, 13.
Mahmoud, N. and Tawfiq, N. (2024). Private tutoring and its social effect on human capital in Egypt: A field study in Cairo Governorate. Journal of the Faculty of Arts, Qena, 33(63), 14-99.
Mansour, Y. (2021). Requirements for activating the role of faculties of education in supporting educational policy in Egypt in light of the experiences of some advanced countries. Journal of Educational and Human Studies, Faculty of Education, Damanhour University, 13(4), Part 3, 418-468.
Marai, M. (2009). Multimedia and its Role in Confronting Private Tutoring. Cairo, Anglo-Egyptian Library. Source: Income and Expenditure Survey for the Year 2019/2020, Central Agency for Public Mobilization and Statistics.
Matar, S. (1987). The relationship between educational research and educational policy-making: A study of some models and factors influencing the interaction between them. Journal of Research and Studies in the Social Sciences, Faculty of Social Sciences, Imam Mohammed Ibn Saud Islamic University, 2nd year, 135-178.
Ministry of Education. Ministerial Resolution, No. (190) regarding the            re-enrollment of students in public secondary schools due to absence, Articles (1) and (2).
Ministry of Education and Technical Education. The Periodical Book, No. (2) Regarding controls and preparations for the new academic year 2024-2025.
Minister of Education. Ministerial Resolution, No. (592) of November 17, 1998, prohibiting private tutoring, Article (1).
Ministry of Education. Ministerial Resolution, No. (149) dated September 1, 2024, regarding the mechanisms for organizing reinforcement and educational support groups.
Ministry of Education. Education Law, No. (139) of 1981.
Ministry of Education. Ministerial Resolution, No. (48) Dated February 23, 1994, regarding reinforcement study groups regarding school reinforcement groups.
Ministry of Education. Ministerial Resolution, No. 180 of 2002 regarding taking legal action against centres operating without a license.
Ministry of Education. Ministerial Resolution, No. 53 dated February 6, 2016.
Ministry of Education. General Bulletin, No. (16) Dated March 18, 1971.
Ministry of Education. The Periodical Book, No. (18) of 2017 regarding preparations for the new academic year 2017/2018.
Ministry of Public Education. Ministerial Resolution, No. (10619) of 1952.
Ministry of Public Education. Ministerial Resolution, No. (10783) of June 21, 1952, regulating the 20% share of school group fees in private schools.
Ministry of Public Education. Ministerial Resolution, No. (11931) of March 17, 1954.
Ministry of Public Education. Ministerial Resolution, No. (7530) of October 29, 1947, regulating the provision of private lessons.
Ministry of Public Education. General Circular, No. (18) of March 21, 1953, File, No. 1/38.
Mohamed, A. (2009). Structural defects in the policies of the Egyptian education system: The phenomenon of private tutoring as a model. The 4th Scientific Conference of the Department of Foundations of Education. Education Systems in Arab Countries: Transgressions and Hope. Faculty of Education, Zagazig University, 1, 45-66. 
Mostafa, N. (2017). Private tutoring and their treatment policies in the United Kingdom, the Republic of Korea and the Arab Republic of Egypt: A comparative study. Journal of the Faculty of Education, Menoufia University, 32(3), 49-121.
Mujahid, H. (2017). The implications of educational waste on the Egyptian economy and ways for confronting it. Journal of Legal and Economic Research, Faculty of Law, Mansoura University, (62), 793-857.
Mujahid, I. (2020). The public secondary school crisis (manifestations, effects, and solutions), 7th Scientific Conference: Quality of education in Egyptian schools (challenges, standards, and opportunities). Faculty of Education, Tanta University, (1), 363-142.
Naguib, K. (2020). School and the formation of the social personality of the Egyptian student. International Journal of Curricula and Technological Education, Cairo University, Graduate School of Education, Arab Society for Advanced Studies in Scientific Curricula, 1, 28-58.
Nawar, A, and Qatit, A. (2020). Rationalizing the phenomenon of private tutoring in pre-university education in Egypt: Proposed regulatory measures. Faculty of Education Journal, 31(124).
Obaidat, S. (2007). Educational Policies in the Arab World. Jordan, Modern World of Books Publishing.
Othman, M. (2020). A Proposed Vision for the Decision-Making Process in Pre-University Education Institutions in Egypt in light of the Experiences of some Countries. Master's Thesis, Beni Suef University, Faculty of Education, Department of Educational Administration.
Qamar, E. (2022). The most significant effects and repercussions of social exclusion in Egyptian education. World of Education Journal, Arab Foundation for Scientific Consultations and Human Resources Development, 78(3), 146-160.
Qandil, A. (1991). Educational policies: Curricula and applications. Arab Journal of Education, Arab League Educational, Cultural and Scientific Organization, 11(2), 42-64.
Robin, B. (2015). Social exclusion: A concept that needs definition. Translated by Mazen Marsoul. Omran Journal of Social Sciences and Humanities, 14(4), 121-139.
Sakran, M. (2010). Educational research from a critical perspective. Journal of the Modern Education Association, 3(8), 34-49.
Salam, M. (2002). A field study of the phenomenon of private tutoring in secondary school in Egypt. Crisis and treatment. Journal of Psychological and Educational Research, Menoufia University, Faculty of Education, 17(3), 78-124.
Samida, K. (2017). Concepts in educational issues, educational policy (1). Education Newspaper, Association of Graduates of Institutes and Faculties of Education, 68(1 and 2), 9-12.
Sani, I. and Yahyaoui, N. (2020). The phenomenon of commodification of education between social and educational factors. Journal of Humanities, University of Larbi Ben M'hidi, Oum El Bouaghi, 7(3), 524-540.
Sayed, A. (2020). An analytical study of educational policy for developing the primary education stage in Egypt since 1980. Journal of Research in Education and Science, 35(2), 112-214.
Sayed, D. (2017). Activating community participation in the educational decision-making process at the school level in some developed countries and the possibility of benefiting from it in Egypt. Educational Journal, Faculty of Education, Sohag University, 50(3), 394-433.
Sedkawi, K. (2016). Private tutoring in the educational system: Causes and effect on students' academic achievement in official examinations. Al-Hikma Journal for Educational and Psychological Studies, Kunooz Al-Hikma Publishing and Distribution Foundation, 7, 216-184.
Shahata, H. and El-Naggar, Z. (2006). Dictionary of Educational and Psychological Terms. Cairo, Egyptian Lebanese House.
Subaih, R. (2022). Comparative studies of shadow education practices in South Korea and Malaysia and their potential use in Egypt. Helwan University, Faculty of Education, 28(12).
Taha, M. (2015). The effect of the decline of the educational role of schools on the spread of shadow education in light of contemporary changes. Arab Studies in Education and Psychology, Arab Educators Association, 63(2), 391-431.
Tala'i, M. (2025). Institutional governance in pre-university education (International experiences, lessons learned). Arab Journal of Management, 45, (1).
Turki, A. (1998). The Parallel School. Alexandria, New Publications House.
Yassin, A. (2011). Student Problems in Education and Ways out of this Crisis. Cairo. Taiba Foundation for Publishing and Distribution, 2011.
Youssef, M. (2019). Proposed procedures for developing the policy-maker selection process. Journal of Educational Administration, (22).
Younis, M. (2015). A critical perspective on the current educational situation in Egypt in light of contemporary educational thought. Criticism and Enlightenment Journal, (1), 17-45.
Younis, N. (2012). Arab Educational Policies. Amman, Osama Publishing and Distribution House.
Zaid, A. (2013). Education and class in Egypt: Integration and marginalization. Journal of the Centre for Social Research and Studies, Faculty of Arts, Cairo University, 11, 9-34.
Zaki, Y. (2006). Private Tutoring: A Facet of the Shadow Economy that Disrupts Educational Strategies. Symposium on development strategies in Arab institutions, League of Arab States in collaboration with the Arab Administrative Development Organization, 54-66.
Zaki, E. (2019). Employing educational research findings in educational policy-making in Egypt: A proposed concept. Fayoum University Journal of Educational and Psychological Sciences, 13(4), 83-128.
Zaki, T. (2024). A proposed vision to confront hidden education in Egypt in light of the experiences of Japan and South Korea. Fayoum University Journal of Educational and Psychological Sciences, Faculty of Education, 9 (18).
Ziadah, M. (2012). Towards a future vision for the educational policy-making process in Egypt. Journal of Education Quality Research and Studies, National Authority for Quality Assurance and Accreditation of Education, 1, 91-125.
ثالثًا: المراجع الأجنبية 
Adams, P. (2016). Education policy: Explaining, framing and forming. Journal of Education Policy, 31(3), 290-307.‏
  Ahlqvist, T., & Rhisiart, M. (2015). Emerging pathways for critical futures research: Changing contexts and impacts of social theory. Futures, 71, 91-104.
Bhorkar, S. and Bray, M. (2018) The expansion and roles of private tutoring in India: from supplementation to supplantation, International Journal of Educational Development, 62, 148–156. doi:10.1016/j.ijedudev.2018.03.003
Bray, M. (2003) Adverse Effects of Private Supplementary Tutoring: Dimensions, Implications and Government Responses (Paris,UNESCO IIEP).
Bray, M. and Kobakhidze, M. N. (2014) The global spread of shadow education. In D. B. Napier (Ed.) Qualities of Education in a Globalised World. The World Council of Comparative Education Societies (Rotterdam, SensePublishers ,185–200). doi:10.1007/978-94-6209-650-9_11. 
Bray, M. (2023). Geographies of shadow education: Patterns and forces in the spatial distributions of private supplementary tutoring. Compare: A Journal of Comparative and International Education, 53(3), 343-360.
‏ Bray, M., & Hajar, A. (2023). Shadow education in the Middle East: Private supplementary tutoring and its policy implications (p. 122). Taylor & Francis.
Bray, M. and Kobakhidze, M. N. (2014) The global spread of shadow education. In D. B. Napier (Ed.) Qualities of Education in a Globalised World. The World Council of Comparative Education Societies (Rotterdam, SensePublishers ,185–200). doi:10.1007/978-94-6209-650-9_11
Bray, M. and Lykins, C. (2012) Shadow Education: Private Supplementary Tutoring and Its Implications for Policy Makers in Asia (Mandaluyong City, Asian Development Bank and Hong Kong, Comparative Education Research Centre, The University of Hong Kong).
Bray, T. M. (2021). Shadow education in Africa: Private supplementary tutoring and its policy implications. Comparative Education Research Centre, The University of Hong Kong.
Da Costa, O., Warnke, P., Cagnin, C., & Scapolo, F. (2018). The impact of foresight on policy-making: insights from the FORLEARN mutual learning process. Technology Analysis & Strategic Management, 20(3), 369-387.
Fontdevila,  C., Verger, A., & Avelar, M. (2021). The business of policy: a review of the corporate sector’s emerging strategies in the promotion of education reform. Critical Studies in Education, 62(2), 131-146.‏
Grey, D., & Osborne, C. (2018). Perceptions and principles of personal tutoring. Journal of Further and Higher Education, 44(3), 285–299. https://doi.org/10.1080/0309877X.2018.1536258.
Gupta, A. (2020) Heterogeneous middle-class and disparate educational advantage: parental investment in their children’s schooling in Dehradun, India, British Journal of Sociology of Education, 41 (1), 48–63. doi:10.1080/01425692.2019.1660142.
Gupta, A. (2021a) Exposing the “shadow”: an empirical scrutiny of the “shadowing process” of private tutoring in India, Educational Review, 1–17. doi:10.1080/00131911.2021.1931038.
Gupta, A. (2022). A ‘shadow education’timescape: An empirical investigation of the temporal arrangements of private tutoring vis-à-vis formal schooling in India. British Journal of Educational Studies, 70(6), 771-787.
Gupta, A. (2021b). Social legitimacy of private tutoring: an investigation of institutional and affective educational practices in India. Discourse: Studies in the Cultural Politics of Education, 43(4), 571–584. https://doi.org/10.1080/01596306.2020.1868978.
Kwon, S. K., Lee, M. and Shin, D. (2017) Educational assessment in the Republic Of Korea: lights and shadows of high-stake exam-based education system, Assessment in Education: Principles, Policy & Practice, 24 (1), 60–77.
Halpin, D. (2005). Researching education policy: Ethical and methodological issues. Routledge.
Lewis, W.D.; Young, T. (2015). Editorial: Education policy implementation revisited. Educ. Policy , 29, 3–17.
Sieverding, M., Krafft, C., & Elbadawy, A. (2019). An exploration of the drivers of private tutoring in Egypt. Comparative Education Review, 63(4), 562-590.
Martha, M. (2012). Commentary Research on Actors and Institutions Involved in Education Policy: Themes, Tensions, and Topics to Explore. In Handbook of education policy research (pp. 842-847). Routledge.
Moschetti, M., Martínez Pons, M., Bordoli, E., & Martinis, P. (2020). The increasing role of non-State actors in education policy-making. Evidence from Uruguay. Journal of Education Policy, 35(3), 367-393.
Liu, J. and Bray, M. (2020) Private subtractory tutoring: the negative impact of shadow education on public schooling in Myanmar, International Journal of Educational Development, Vol, 76,  No,38, 121-143.  doi:10.1016/j.ijedudev.2020.102213.
Mavrot, C., Potluka, O., Balzer, L., Eicher, V., Haunberger, S., Heuer, C., & Viallon, F. X. (2025). What evaluation criteria are used in policy evaluation research: A cross-field literature review. Evaluation and Program Planning, 108 , 2.118-142.
McCoy, S., & Byrne, D. (2024). Shadow education uptake in Ireland: Inequalities and wellbeing in a high-stakes context. British Journal of Educational Studies, 1-27.
Muthanna, A., & Sang, G. (2023). A conceptual model of the factors affecting education policy implementation. Education Sciences, 13(3), 260.
Nichols, S. L. (2024). Educational psychology and educational policy: Intersections and new directions. In Handbook of educational psychology (pp. 162-188). Routledge.
Owen, G. T. (2014). Qualitative methods in higher education policy analysis: Using interviews and document analysis. The qualitative report, 19(26), 1-19.
Lao, R. (2014). Analyzing the Thai state policy on private tutoring: the prevalence of the market discourse. Asia Pacific Journal of Education, 34(4), 476–491. https://doi.org/10.1080/02188791.2014.960799.
Gupta, A. (2021a) Exposing the “shadow”: an empirical scrutiny of the “shadowing process” of private tutoring in India, Educational Review, 1–17. doi:10.1080/00131911.2021.1931038.
Hajar, A., & Karakus, M. (2024). Coming out of the shadows: investing in English private tutoring at a transition point in Kazakhstan’s education system during the global pandemic. The Language Learning Journal, 52(5), 571-584.
Van der Steen, M. (2017). Anticipation tools in policy formulation: Forecasting, foresight and implications for policy planning. In Handbook of policy formulation (pp. 182-197). Edward Elgar Publishing.
Van Maaren, J., Jensen, M., & Foster, A. (2022). Tutoring in higher education during COVID-19: Lessons from a private university’s transition to remote learning. Journal of College Reading and Learning, 52(1), 3-22.‏
Viennet, R., & Pont, B. (2017). Education policy implementation: A literature review and proposed framework
YUNG, W. H. K., KONG, S. H. E., & FONG, N. (2024, April). Conceptualizing shadow education as a form of oppression in the context of high-stakes testing. In 2024 Annual Meeting of American Educational Research Association:" Dismantling Racial Injustice and Constructing Educational Possibilities: A Call to Action".
Punjabi, S. (2020) Is shadow education becoming the ‘new’ formal? Effects of pedagogical approaches of IIT-JEE coaching on school education in the City of Delhi, Contemporary Education Dialogue, 17 (1), 14–44.
Heyneman, S. P. (2011). Private tutoring and social cohesion. Peabody journal of education, 86(2), 183-188.‏
 Zhan, S. (2014). The private tutoring industry in Taiwan: Government policies and their implementation. Asia Pacific Journal of Education, 34(4), 492-504.‏
Zhang, W. and Bray, M. (2020) Comparative research on shadow education: achievements, challenges, and the agenda ahead, European Journal of Education, 55 (3), 322–341. doi:10.1111/ejed.12413.
رابعًا: مواقع إلكترونية
دبش، حمدي (2023). من السناتر إلى الأون لاين هل فشلت المنظومة الذكية لـ«التعليم» في القضاء على الدروس الخصوصية؟  9 / 11 / 2023، متاحة على:
https://www.almasryalyoum.com/news/details/3026147              
منصة العدالة الاجتماعية (2021) . تقرير الدروس الخصوصية في مصر، متاحة علي: info@siplatform.org                                     
سامي، محمد أمين (2023). السياسة التعليمية في مواجهة تحديات المستقبل، متاحة علي: https://sustainability-excellence.com              
الموسوعة الحرة ويكيبيديا، قائمة بأسماء الوزراء الذين تولوا وزارة التعليم في حكومات مصر. متاحة على:
  https://ar.wikipedia.org/wiki                                     
نصار، جمال (2022). الدروس الخصوصية والتعليم في مصر في مهب الريح، متاحة علي، https://gamalnassar.com  
المصري اليوم وزير التربية والتعليم شركات ستتولى مسئولية مجموعات التقوية لمنافسة السناتر متاحة علي:  https://www.almasryalyoum.com 
دبش، حمدي (2024). خبراء تعليم عن الدروس الخصوصية: «عادة مجتمعية».. وكل المحاولات انتهت بـ«الفشل» شحاتة: لا فرق بين الحكومي والخاص.. الكُل يعاني، متاحة على:
https://www.almasryalyoum.com/news/details/3025879             
جمهورية مصر العربية، حسين كامل بهاء الدين وزير التربية والتعليم بشأن حظر الدروس الخصوصية، قرار رقم (592) لسنة   1988 متاح على: https: www east laws com data Tash details 83335
غريب، محمد وآخرون (2023). بحضور وزير التعليم العالي «الشيوخ» يناقش هجرة الطالب والمدرس من المدرسة لأجل الدروس الخصوصية، 23 / 1 / 2023، متاحة على:
https://www.almasryalyoum.com/news/details/2800063             
يحيى، وفاء، علام، يمنى (2022). وزير التعليم يحسم الجدل حول «الدروس الخصوصية»، متاحة على:https://www.almasryalyoum.com/news/details/2734870         
السلامونى، حنين (2022). تقنين أم إغلاق؟ «سناتر الدروس الخصوصية» لم تحدد موقفها بعد، 27 / 12 / 2022، متاحة علي: https://www.almasryalyoum.com/news/details/2778401
الجندي (2023). بسبب الخلاف على الدروس الخصوصية.. إصابة والدة تلميذ على يد مدرس في مشاجرة بشبرا الخيمة، 21 / 10 / 2023، متاحة على:
https://www.almasryalyoum.com/news/details/3011562                               
الجندي (2023). المشدد 7 سنوات لمدرس فقأ عين زوج شقيقته بسبب «فلوس» الدروس الخصوصية بالقليوبية، متاحة على:https://www.almasryalyoum.com/news/details/2818102       
      
وزارة التخطيط والتنمية الاقتصادية (2022). الأجندة الوطنية للتنمية المستدامة، رؤية مصر2030 المحدثة. متاحة على: https://mped.gov.eg/files/egypt2030.pdf