The administrative reality of Umm Al-Qura University in Makkah Al-Mukarramah in light of the Excellence Management entrance and the requirements for its development

Qari, Muhammad Bin Abdullah Abdul Rahim; Haz, Muhammad Sabry; Al Shafei, Faraj Mustafa

doi:10.21608/jsrep.2022.239573

The administrative reality of Umm Al-Qura University in Makkah Al-Mukarramah in light of the Excellence Management entrance and the requirements for its development

Document Type : Original Article

Authors

Department of Management, Planning and Comparative Studies, Faculty of Education, Al-Azhar University

10.21608/jsrep.2022.239573

Abstract

The study aimed to develop the administration of Umm Al-Qura University in Makkah in the light of the excellence management approach, and to identify the most important models of its application in university education in contemporary management thought. The study used the descriptive approach, and the questionnaire was used as a tool to identify the reality of Umm Al-Qura University management in light of the excellence management approach. The study tool (the questionnaire) was applied to a sample that included (199) among the dean of faculties and their deans, officials of planning and development units, quality officials at the university, and some senior management leaders. The study reached a set of results, the most important of which are: All the axes of the questionnaire came in terms of the degree of verification at the level of (medium), and the study showed that there were no statistically significant differences between the opinions of the study sample according to the college variable (practical, theoretical, legal) about the degree of verification of the leadership dimension. creativity, policies, strategies, human resources management, operations management, relationship management, resources, results, and obstacles to the application of Excellence Management at Umm Al-Qura University, while there were significant differences about the degree of achievement of the dimension of focus on students and scientific research and the requirements for applying Excellence Management at Umm Al-Qura University in favor of Sharia colleges. The study was presented in accordance with the main objective of developing the administration of Umm Al-Qura University in Makkah in light of the Excellence Department approach in the form of a set of requirements.

Highlights

Keywords

Full Text

References

Ibrahim Abdullah Al-Munif (1999). The Evolution of Contemporary Administrative Thought, Second Edition, Riyadh: Dar Al-Ibdaa Internationale, p. 536.

Ibrahim Othman Abdul Rahman (2014 AD). Concepts of performance quality and institutional excellence: a reference to the Excellence Model of the European Foundation for Quality Management (EFQM. 2013), the twenty-fifth conference of the Arab Federation for Libraries and Information entitled Standards of performance quality in libraries, information centers and archives, Tunis, pp. 87-111.

Ahmed Al Yamani (2016 AD). The most prominent challenges facing university education, Journal of Administrative Development, Saudi Arabia, Institute of Public Administration, Public Relations and Media Department, p. 137, p. 11.

Ahmed Mohamed Al-Tayeb, Juma Al-Bashti (2004 AD). Creative leadership, change management and development: strategic management and administrative excellence, the fifth annual Arab conference in the management of creativity and innovation, the role of the Arab director in creativity and excellence. Sharm El Sheikh - Arab Republic of Egypt 27-29 November 2004 AD, p. 86.

Ahmad Muhammad Abd al-Salam al-Ashqar, Ahmad Abd al-Fattah Hamdi al-Hindawi (2017) A proposed conception to achieve institutional excellence for the faculties of Al-Azhar University in the light of the EFQM model, Journal of Education, p. 175, part 3, College of Education, Al-Azhar University, pp. 528-611.

Osama Khairy (2014 AD). Organizational Excellence, Amman, Dar Al-Raya for Publishing and Distribution, p. 11.

Carl Thor (1998). Measures of Success, translated by Amal Mansour, Saudi Arabia: International Ideas House, p. 217.

Umm Al-Qura University in Makkah: Strategic Plan 1439 AH / 1441 AD (2018 AD / 2020 AD), p. 25.

Umm Al-Qura University in Makkah Al-Mukarramah: Executive Plan 1439 AH / 1440 AH, pp. 5-10.

Hussein Al-Douri (2008 AD). Strategic management and administrative excellence, conference proceedings: Strategic management and support for the competitive capabilities of Arab public and private institutions, Egypt, Cairo, Arab Administrative Development Organization, p. 251.

Rashid bin Musalat Al-Sharif, Mustafa Zakaria Ahmed (2015 AD): A proposed conception for the development of the Deanship of Community Service and Continuing Education at the University of Tabuk in the light of the Excellence Department entrance, Education Journal, p. 162, Part 2, Faculty of Education, Al-Azhar University, p. 179.

Reda Ibrahim Al-Meligy (2012 AD). Management of Institutional Excellence: Between Theory and Practice, Cairo, World of Books, p. 37.

Ramzi Ahmed Abdel Hai (2007) Evaluating the performance of university administration in the light of total quality management. Alexandria: Dar Al-Wafaa for the world of printing and publishing, p. 31.

Sameh Abdul Muttalib Amer (2013 AD). Administrative Excellence in the Twenty-First Century, Cairo, Thebes for Publishing and Distribution, p. 8.

Saeed Ismail Ali (1999 AD). University affair. Cairo: World of Books, p. 136.

Sufian Kamal (2003 AD). Ensuring good awareness in open and distance education, Al-Quds Open University Journal for Research and Studies, Vol. 1, p. 1, pp. 25-26.

Sultan Saeed Abdo Al-Mikhlafi (2018 AD). The degree of application of the leadership of King Khalid University to the standards of management excellence in the light of the European Model of Excellence EFQM from the point of view of the university’s faculty members, International Journal of Educational Research, United Arab Emirates University, Vol. 42, p. 3, pp. 154-195.

Syed Muhammad Jadralb (2013 AD). Management of Creativity and Competitive Excellence, Cairo, Egyptian Book House, p. 116.

Saleh bin Suleiman Al-Rasheed (2004 AD). Towards building a framework for an approach to creativity and business excellence in Arab organizations, Egypt, the Fifth Annual Arab Conference on Management, Creativity and Renewal. The Role of the Arab Teacher on November 29 - Creativity and Excellence, Sharm El Sheikh, p. 23.

Saleh bin Suleiman Al-Rasheed (2009). Excellence in performance: what it is and how it can be achieved in business organizations, Emirates, Research and Documentation Center, Afaq Economic Magazine, Vol. 29, p. 116, p. 114.

Dahi Khalfan Tamim (2003). Excellence Education Conference. Dubai: The Electronic College for Total Quality, p. 2.

Adel Mohamed Zayed (2005 AD). Distinguished Organizational Performance: The Path to the Future Organization, Cairo, Arab Administrative Development Organization, p. 169.

Adel Mohamed Zayed (2006 AD). The Path to Distinguished Organizational Performance, Center for Research and Commercial Studies, Faculty of Commerce, Cairo University, p. 11.

Atef El-Deeb (2008). Franchise management. Egypt: Suez Canal University, Research Paper for the Ninth Annual Conference "Towards a System of Arab Administrative Excellence", Cataract Pyramid Resort, April 9-11, 2008, p. 16.

Ali Al-Din Hilal (1989 AD). Future Horizons and Education Development, in the Arab Thought Forum - The Future of Education Project in the Arab World, The Future of the Global System and Experiences of Education Development, 1st Edition, Jordan: Amman, p. 34.

Ali Al-Salami (2002). Excellence Management: Management Models and Techniques in the Age of Knowledge, Cairo, Dar Gharib for Publishing and Distribution, p. 20.

Ali Muhammad Al-Sinani (2010 AD). Developing the institutional performance of Imam Muhammad bin Saud Islamic University in the light of the Excellence Management Approach. Journal of Education, Al-Azhar University - Egypt, p. 144, vol. 7, p. 194.

Awad, Badir Al-Haddad (2003). Components of customer service-oriented corporate culture, Management of the Age magazine, Issue 43, Arab Management Association, Cairo, p. 41.

Ghassan Gharib Douiri (2006). Excellence Management in the Jordanian Public Sector "A field study from the point of view of managers on the extent to which the standards of excellence are applied". Unpublished Master's Thesis, Faculty of Economics and Administrative Sciences, Yarmouk University, Jordan, p. 40.

Fahad Hamid Muhammad Al-Thaqafi (2019 AD). The reality of the application of the contents of knowledge management in the management of Taif education and its relationship to institutional excellence from the point of view of the leaders working in it, the Educational Journal, College of Education, Sohag University, vol. 57, pp. 193-224.

Al-Hassan Abdullah Bashiwa et al. (2013). Institutional excellence, the entrance to quality and best practices, principles and applications. Amman: Al-Warraq Establishment for Publishing and Distribution, p. 36.

Majed Muhammad Al-Farra (2015 AD) The Reality of Excellence Management at Al-Aqsa University according to the EFQM European Discrimination Model, Journal of the Islamic University for Economic and Administrative Studies, Scientific Research and Graduate Studies Affairs at the Islamic University, Gaza, Palestine, Vol. 23, v. 2, pp. 1-29.

Arabic Language Academy (1985). Intermediate Dictionary. i 3. Cairo: Offset Presses of the Eastern Advertising Company, Volume 2, p. 929.

Muhammad bin Fahd bin Mutlaq Al-Luqan (2011 AD). Excellence management in Saudi universities, a proposed conception in the light of international standards for organizational excellence, unpublished Ph.D. thesis, College of Education, Umm Al-Qura University in Makkah, p. 38.

Mohamed Gad Hassanein (2015) Developing Institutional Performance at South Valley University in the Light of Excellence Standards for the European Foundation for Quality Management: The European Model for Excellence Management, Journal of Educational Administration, Egyptian Association for Comparative Education and Educational Administration, Egypt, Second Year, p. 7, pp. 15-176 .

Muhammad Abdul Rahman Al-Aydi (2005 AD). The development of higher education - an administrative vision, the first Arab conference on the Orientalization of the future of higher education - Egypt, Sharm el-Sheikh: the Arab Organization for Administrative Development, p. 186.

Medhat Muhammad Abu Al-Nasr (2014 AD). Distinguished Administrative Performance, Cairo, The Arab Group for Training and Publishing, p. 67.

Mustafa Bahi, Faten El-Nimr (2009). Evaluation in the field of educational and psychological sciences: principles, theories, and applications, Cairo, Anglo-Egyptian, p. 107.

Kingdom of Saudi Arabia, Ministry of Planning (2005 AD): Eighth Development Plan (1425 - 1430 AH), p. 33.

Kingdom of Saudi Arabia, Ministry of Education (2009). Quoted from the Higher Education website, dated 4/5/2015 AD, available at the following link: http://www.mohe.gov.sa/ar/studyinside/Government-Universities/Pages/default.aspx

Mona Ahmed Mohamed Hamouda (2009 AD). A proposed framework for the application of excellence management to raise the efficiency of performance in universities. Journal of Financial and Commercial Research (Faculty of Commerce, Port Said University), Egypt, Vol. 2, p. 428.

Al-Hilali Al-Sherbiny Al-Hilali, Amani Ghabbour (2013 AD). Entrance to Excellence Management and the requirements for its application at Mansoura University, Journal of the Future of Arab Education, Egypt, Vol. 20, p. 83, pp. 11-142.

Hana Shehta El-Sayed Mandour (2014). Requirements to achieve organizational excellence in Egyptian universities: an analytical study, Journal of Educational Administration - The Egyptian Association for Comparative Education and Educational Administration - Egypt, Q1, P2, p. 279.

Youssef Rizkallah Al-Susi (2015 AD) The degree of technical colleges’ practice in the governorates of Gaza to manage excellence and its relationship to competitive advantage, unpublished master’s thesis, College of Education, Islamic University of Gaza.

ثالثا: المراجع الأجنبية

A.K. Sen Gupta &Vikram Parekh (2009) Excellence in Higher Education in India: Way Forward, Journal of Emerging Knowledge on Emerging Markets, Volume 1 Issue 1.

Alrayes, Raed(2003). Quantities Analysis Of The Self Assessment Score Of 45 Organizations Which Were Assessed By EFQM Excellence Model, For Master Degree, United Kingdom: Sheffield Hallam University, p.4.

Damon A.Williams, Berger, Joseph B.,McClendon, Shederick (2005). Toward a model of inclusive excellence and change in postsecondary institutions. Association of American Colleges and Universities,p.5.

EGAN, Steve (2003). Embracing Excellence In Education, England, Sheffield HallamUniversit, P 8.

Faraj, S. I. (2018). Assessing Excellence Management in the Light of the European Excellence Model at Taif University. International Journal of Education and Literacy Studies, 6(4), 175-186.‏

Faraji. R &et.al (2014)Performance Evaluation Based on EFQM Excellence Model in Sport Organizations, International Journal of Academic Research in Business and Social Sciences,June 2012, Vol. 2, No. 6.

Light, Greg & Cox, Roy. (2001). Learning and teaching in higher education. London: Paul Chapman Publishhing, p.4.

Loukas N.Anninos (2007). The archetype of excellence in universities and TQM. Journal of Management History, Vol.13, No.4, p.315.

Nadaf. Z &M.H. Siddiqui (2016) Achieving Excellence in Higher Education, international Journal of Scientific Research 3.

Olson, L.(2009):An Examination of Quality Management in Support Functions of Elementary and Secondary Education Using the Malcolm Baldrige National Quality Award’s Criteria for Performance Excellence, A dissertation, submitted to the faculty of the graduate school of the university of Minnesota of philosophy.

Peters,T. J. &Waterman ,H(2004): In Search Of Excellence, Second Edition, London: Profile Books, pp.13-15

Porter ,L.J. &Tanner, S.J(2004): Assessing Business Excellence, 2nd Edit., Oxford: Publishing Elsevier Butterworth Heinemann, p.4.

Pupius, Mike (2008). Achieving excellence in education in Europe, Sheffield Hallam University, p.6.

Saris E, et al (2004): Methods for Testing and Evaluating Survey Questionnaires, Hoboken, New Jersey .John Wiley & Sons, Inc., p p . 275-280.

Sheffield HallamUniversity(2003): Applying Self Assessment Against The EFQM Excellence Model In Further And Higher Education .United Kingdom: Higher Education Funding Council For England(HEFCE), p.9.